Jimmy John's vs Firehouse

Jimmy John’s vs Firehouse Subs: A Sandwich Showdown

Last Updated on April 19, 2024 by Shari Mason

Confronted with the task of finding a tasty and efficient sandwich, I was caught between two outstanding choices: Jimmy John’s or Firehouse?

These two popular sandwich chains offer mouthwatering options that cater to different tastes. 

In this comparison, I’ll share the flavors, speed, and overall experience to help you decide which one suits your sandwich cravings best. Keep reading. 

The Sub Shop Showdown: Jimmy John’s vs Firehouse Subs

Jimmy John's Restaurant

In the battle of sandwiches, Jimmy John’s and Firehouse Subs each have their special traits. 

Firehouse Subs uses really good meats and cheeses, making their subs taste great. But it’s a bit pricey, with sandwiches costing around $13 to $16. 

As such, their top sub, The Hook and Ladder, is about $9.55 for a medium-sized one. Now, Jimmy John’s serves regular sandwiches along with subs. 

They are unique in how fast they make your food – they’re quick. While their sandwiches are good, the toppings make them stand out. 

They might not be the best in the country, but they’re pretty tasty. So, when picking between these two places, you decide between quality and speed.

A Quick Table Guide

AspectJimmy John’sFirehouse Subs
Menu ComparisonOffers a variety of subs, limited bread choicesTastier subs with a better bread selection, and various options
PriceWallet-friendly, around $6 for an 8-inch subSlightly pricier, about 15% more than Jimmy John’s
Locations2,600 locations nationwide, known for “Freaky Fast” deliveryAbout 1,200 locations in the United States, available through other delivery services
Ingredients QualityFreshly baked bread, sliced-in-house roast beef, smoked ham, turkey, and cheesesStreamlined bread selection, high-quality meats and cheeses, steamed for flavor
Taste and FlavorsCustomizable options, a range of flavorsUnique cooking method, high-quality meats and cheeses, secret sauce
Health OptionsIt has Plain Slims sandwiches, customizable for dietary preferencesLighter options under 500 calories, salads, low-calorie dressings
Customer ServiceMixed reviews, quick service, quality ingredientsVaried feedback, occasional issues with food quality and cost

Key Differences

A. Menu Comparison

In the Italian Sub category, both chains offered similar meat quality. Still, Firehouse Subs earned the edge due to its better bread and more generous use of spices, resulting in a tastier sub.

Moving on to the Club Sandwiches, the Turkey Bacon Ranch from Firehouse Subs outshone Jimmy John’s Club Lulu due to less generous meat portions and subpar bread quality.

Regarding veggie subs, neither establishment managed to impress fully—however, Jimmy John’s has a slight advantage in this category. 

Lastly, Firehouse Subs again emerged in the tuna club category, delivering a tastier Tuna Sub with more pronounced pickle and pepper sensations. 

Unfortunately, Jimmy John’s Tuna Club fell short, failing to capture the necessary elements for a memorable tuna sub. 

While neither establishment emerged as a winner, Firehouse Subs appeared to have the upper hand in most of these sandwich battles, making it the preferred choice for discerning palates.

B. Price Point

If you want to buy a sandwich with a wallet-friendly factor, Jimmy John’s and Firehouse Subs differ in pricing. 

At Jimmy John’s, you can grab an 8-inch sub for around $6.00, keeping things simple with a consistent size. 

“Life is good when you have a good sandwich.”

Keanu Reeves, Canadian Actor

However, over at Firehouse Subs, you’ll find slightly pricier options. Firehouse Subs costs about 15% more than Jimmy John’s. 

While both places have their pricing strategies, it’s clear that you can find budget-friendly choices at both.

C. Locations & Availability

Jimmy John’s stands tall with an impressive 2600 locations nationwide, ensuring a fresh, delectable sub is always close. 

What sets them apart is their reputation for “Freaky Fast” delivery, committed to getting your sandwich to you with lightning speed.

On the other hand, Firehouse Subs has about 1200 locations in the United States, which is also quite impressive. 

While they may be slower with their deliveries than Jimmy John’s, they can still bring your sandwich to you through other delivery services.

But what’s the difference between Jimmy John’s and Subway?

Quality Of Ingredients 

Jimmy John’s takes pride in their freshly baked bread, including options like Classic French and 9-Grain Wheat, which many customers appreciate for its freshness and quality. 

Their subs feature sliced-in-house roast beef [1], smoked ham, turkey, and cheeses, ensuring a daily dose of freshness.

They also offer a variety of healthy veggies like lettuce, tomatoes, sprouts, and jumbo kosher dill pickles to enhance the overall sandwich experience.

Meanwhile, Firehouse Subs offers a more streamlined bread selection, with wheat, white, and gluten-free choices. 

But where they shine is with their hot subs. They use high-quality meats and cheeses and steam them together to make the flavors pop.

Firehouse Subs puts a lot of effort into their ingredients, especially in their famous Firehouse Hero sub. 

It’s got roast beef, smoked turkey, Virginia honey ham, and melty provolone cheese – a flavor explosion in every bite.

Find out how Jimmy John’s differs from Jersey Mike’s here.

Taste & Flavor Profile

Firehouse Subs takes a different approach, focusing on elevating the sandwich experience. 

They use high-quality meats and cheeses, and their secret sauce perfectly steers everything. 

This unique cooking method brings out the deep, savory flavors of the ingredients, resulting in hearty and mouthwatering sandwiches. 

Now, for Jimmy John’s, customers can pick and choose their favorite ingredients and toppings to create their ideal sandwich. 

Whether you fancy a classic turkey and cheese combo or want to venture with roast beef and avocado, they have a range of flavors to cater to your taste buds.

But how does Jimmy John’s Slims differ from its regular sandwich?

Health & Dietary Considerations

Regarding health and dietary options, Jimmy John’s caters to those mindful of calories and fat with their Plain Slims sandwiches. 

For instance, the Slim 1 (ham and provolone) trims down 90 calories compared to the Slim 5 [2]. 

Their Veggie sandwich can be customized to fit vegetarian or vegan preferences by omitting the cheese and mayo. 

It’s satisfying with various veggies, delivering lower calories and carbs. Next, Firehouse Subs presents a range of lighter alternatives without compromising taste. 

Some of their subs stay under 500 calories, balancing flavor and nutrition. 

“Choose Jimmy John’s for a fast meal on the go, or Firehouse Subs for a fiery feast that’ll light up your day.”

Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

The menu also includes salads and an array of low-calorie dressings, making it a go-to for those seeking lighter or vegetarian meal options.

Customer Service

Lately, Firehouse Subs has been getting many unhappy customer feedback. Many customers say their food could be better and cost less. 

Some have even needed help with wrong or missing orders, leaving them disappointed. 

On one side, Jimmy John’s has had its share of complaints, mainly about sandwiches being too thin and not so good.

But here’s the thing – they take action to make things right, keeping their customers happy. Plus, some people love the fantastic taste of their ingredients. 

They appreciate that Jimmy John’s is quick, serves quality sandwiches, and cares about being responsible with their food. 

Read: Papa John’s vs Pizza Hut


What is Jimmy John’s competitive advantage?

Jimmy John’s gains a competitive edge by specializing in cold subs that can be made and delivered within an impressive 10-minute timeframe. 

This swift service sets them apart from earlier competitors and underscores their commitment to efficiency.

What meat brand does Firehouse use?

Firehouse Subs uses Boar’s Head meats for their sandwiches, emphasizing a commitment to quality and premium ingredients. 

In A Nutshell

Several distinct differences have emerged in the battle of Jimmy John’s vs. Firehouse Subs. 

Jimmy John’s stands out with its commitment to customization, offering fresh ingredients and a wide range of flavors for those who prefer a personalized sandwich experience. 

Their proactive approach to customer concerns adds to their appeal. 

On the other hand, Firehouse Subs takes pride in its premium ingredients, steamed to perfection, resulting in hearty and savory subs. 

While both chains cater to different tastes and dietary preferences, prioritizing personalization and responsiveness (Jimmy John’s) or savoring premium ingredients and unique cooking methods (Firehouse Subs) in your sandwich journey is the ultimate choice.


Shari Mason

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *