Best Store-Bought Pizza Sauce

20 Best Store-Bought Pizza Sauce Options

Last Updated on May 17, 2024 by Shari Mason

One should not downplay the importance of pizza sauce in making a delicious pizza. Given the plethora of options available in grocery stores, finding the right one can indeed be challenging.

We decided to buy highly recommended sauces to find the ultimate best store-bought pizza sauce. Trust us; we’ve tasted and ranked everything from classic marinara to bold and spicy creations.

We will guide you through the top options that deliver convenience without sacrificing flavor. Read on to find your new go-to fully-prepared pizza sauce.

Top 20 Store-Bought Pizza Sauces (Ranked)

1. Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauce

Best Italian Tomato Sauce on a Pot

Average Price: roughly $4.99

Why We Love It: Rao’s Homemade pizza sauce is thick, flavorful, and has the right balance of sweet flavor and acidity, perfect as a cheese pizza.

It is a great option for making homemade pizzas, calzones, and other Italian dishes. We recommend topping it with mozzarella cheese, parmesan cheese, or cheddar cheese.

Rao’s is a high-quality sweet pizza sauce made from natural ingredients, such as whole peeled tomatoes, Italian cherry tomatoes, onions, salt, fresh garlic, and fresh basil.

This best store-bought pizza condiment is free from preservatives, artificial flavors, and colors, making it a healthier choice for pizza lovers. [1]

Read: How Long Does Pizza Sauce Last In The Fridge?

2. Victoria Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly$7.99

Why We Love It: It is a fresh sauce ideal for making a traditional pizza at home because it is thick and tasty.

The sauce is gluten-free and free of preservatives and artificial flavors. The 16-ounce container of Victoria pizza sauce is practical and straightforward to use and store.

3. Paesana Classic Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly$22

Why We Love It: Olives, vine-ripened diced tomatoes, and a combination of herbs and spices make Paesana Classic pizza sauce, giving it a rich and savory flavor.

This best store-bought pizza sauce is also free of gluten, artificial colors, and preservatives, making it a healthier alternative for pizza lovers.

The 8.5-ounce jar of Paesana Classic pizza sauce is a practical container that is simple to use and store.

4. Barilla Traditional Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly$2.62

Why We Love It: It is produced with premium, natural ingredients, including olives, vine-ripened tomatoes, and a combination of herbs and spices.

We noticed that its thick and chunky texture makes it easy to spread over pizza crusts, giving the food a rich, authentic flavor that improves its overall flavor.

This traditional Italian pizza sauce is free of preservatives and added sugars, making it a more tasty and healthy substitute for other available store-bought pizza sauces.

5. Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

Pizza Sauce on a Stainless Bowl

Average Price: roughly$4.00

Why We Love It: This sauce has strong tomato and well-balanced garlic flavors.

The hearty pizza sauce at Muir Glen was thicker than most of the others we tasted, but this is in no way a negative. This sauce’s thicker consistency made it the perfect choice for topping a handmade crust.

6. Sclafani Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly$5.99

Why We Love It: Sclafani crushed has been our go-to basis for our sauce for a while, and we’ve been generally satisfied with the product.

Although it is one of the sweetest and best-tasting tomatoes we’ve ever eaten, they don’t, in our opinion, go well with our pizza. As strange as it may sound, this store-bought pizza sauce is far too sweet and rich.

7. Williams Sonoma San Marzano Pizza Sauce 

Average Price: roughly$17

Why We Love It: It is a high-quality store-bought pizza sauce made with San Marzano tomatoes known for its sweet, flavorful taste and low acidity.

“Unlock the secret to extraordinary pizza perfection with each spoonful of the finest store-bought pizza sauce, as it cascades over your taste buds, igniting a culinary adventure that transcends ordinary boundaries.”

Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

The volcanic dirt in Italy is where the tomatoes are grown, which makes them taste and look better. [2]

Extra-virgin olives, sea salt, and a mix of herbs make the sauce, giving this best store-bought pizza sauce a rich, spicy, and fresh taste.

8. Mario Batali Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly$2.75

Why We Love It: This sauce is made with high-quality ingredients, giving homemade pies a rich, real taste. It tastes good and has a smooth texture, so pizza fans will enjoy it.

9. Yo Mama’s Classic Pizza Sauce 

Average Price: roughly$1.75

Why We Love It: There is no single sugar in the ingredients of this store-bought pasta sauce. Although wide tomato varieties have a sweeter flavor, manufacturers occasionally include sugar or other sweeteners to simulate the natural sweetness.

10. Mezzetta Pizza Sauce

pizza sauce on a pan

Average Price: roughly$5.19

Why We Love It: Mezzetta Pizza Sauce is a flavorful and convenient sauce that enhances homemade pizza creations. Made with ripe tomatoes, aromatic herbs, and spices, it delivers a rich and authentic Italian taste.

This delicious sauce is carefully crafted to achieve the perfect consistency, allowing it to spread smoothly over your pizza dough.

11. 365 Everyday Value Organic Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly $4

Why We Love It: This sauce is vegan-friendly, organically grown, and produced with delicious organic olive oil.

It is produced with the standard components you would often find and anticipate in store-bought pizza sauces.

For added flavor, it also contains organic dried basil, organic black pepper, and organic chile pepper.

12. Hunt’s Garlic & Herb Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly$1.18

Why We Love It: This sauce is wonderful with your favorite pasta meals because it combines savory herbs with a rich, deep garlic taste.

We frequently prepare spaghetti using this brand and flavor. We discover that one can provide enough food for the entire family to eat leftovers. This sauce has a good flavor; you don’t need to add much more.

13. Ragú Homemade Style Pizza Sauce 

Average Price: roughly$4.00

Why We Love It: These four-pack 14-ounce jars produce enough sauce for numerous pies. The taste and consistency are on par with those of other pizza sauces.

This is mainly because the recipe relies only on vine-ripened tomatoes, olive oil, and spices like other excellent pizza sauces. High fructose corn syrup, artificial flavors, or additional colors are also absent.

14. Contadina Pizza Squeeze Original Pizza Sauce 

Average Price: roughly$2.00

Why We Love It: The fact that this pizza sauce is packaged in a convenient squeeze bottle makes it stand out.

Kids can grasp the packaging well and press sauce exactly where it needs to be rather than fumbling with spoons that invariably result in spills. However, it’s not just about comfort.

The affordable sauce is non-GMO, tastes wonderful, has a nice consistency, and is packed in the USA. [3]

15. Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

Close Up Shot of a Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly$3.00

Why We Love It: Only five ingredients make up Don Pepino pizza sauce, free of preservatives, starches, added color, artificial sugar, citric acid, and gums.

The other components are tomatoes, corn oil, salt, onion powder, and garlic powder. Additionally, corn oil, not olive oil, is used in producing the product.

16. Otamot Organic Pizza Sauce 

Average Price: roughly$6.00

Why We Love It: It contains carrots, sweet potatoes, butternut squash, red beet, and red bell pepper. It is also made of organic vine-ripened tomatoes, olive oil, sweet onion, basil, white balsamic vinegar, and garlic.

We like that the typical tomato flavor is more robust than all those concealed vegetables.

17. Cento San Marzano Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly$1.79

Why We Love It: One of the things that made this Cento canned pizza sauce one of our faves was its thick, smooth, solid consistency.

It is incredibly spreadable and one of the simplest to distribute evenly across a pizza crust. The sauce is created with non-GMO fresh tomatoes, and the can’s plastic lining is BPA-free.

18. Pomi Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly $4.00

Why We Love It: The sweet and salty flavors of the tomatoes alone in this pizza sauce give a fantastic and zesty flavor. But the herbs in this sauce were a little softer.

19. Pastorelli Pizza Sauce

Average Price: roughly$2.50

Why We Love It: This sauce hasrich, zesty, and tomato-flavored sauce. It contains tomato puree, citric acid, garlic, imported pecorino romano cheese, canola oil, extra virgin olive oil, and spices.

This product is ideal for people who avoid preservatives and corn syrup and follow a gluten-free diet. We didn’t worry about consuming chemicals we’re unaware of because the sauce’s can is produced using BPA-free materials. [4]

20. Classico Traditional Pizza Sauce

Pizza Sauce on a Bowl

Average Price: roughly $2.62

Why We Love It: We specifically liked the thick, rich texture and deep red color of Classico’s take on pizza sauce.

“Came From A Plant, Eat It; Was Made In A Plant, Don’t.”

– Michael Pollan, Author, and Journalist

The herb-forwardness of this sauce, though, was what stood out the most. The flavor that stood out most was basil. Black pepper and oregano were in excellent proportion, as well.


u003cstrongu003eWhat kind of sauce do pizzerias use?u003c/strongu003e

The most common sauce in traditional pizzerias is a simple tomato sauce made from crushed or pureed tomatoes, sometimes flavored with herbs such as basil and oregano.u003cbru003eu003cbru003eThis classic tomato sauce provides the base for many homemade pizza sauces and variations.

u003cstrongu003eAre pizza sauce and marinara sauce the same thing?u003c/strongu003e

No, pizza sauce and marinara sauce are not the same thing. Pizza sauce is the canned sauce used in a pizza pie made of tomato juice or pureed tomato paste.u003cbru003eu003cbru003eMeanwhile, the marinara paste is commonly used in pasta dishes as a dipping sauce. It is made from organic tomatoes, garlic, fresh onions, olive oil, and herbs such as basil and organic oregano.

Wrapping Up  

In conclusion, Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauis is the best pizza sauce among the best store-bought pizza sauces. Its rich, extra pizza sauce flavor, authentic ingredients, and dedication to quality make it a top choice among the best pizza sauces at a local grocery store.

“Unlock the extraordinary essence of pizza with the elixir of flavors found in the finest store-bought pizza sauce. It’s the secret ingredient that transforms a mere slice into an enchanting gastronomic experience.”

– Eat Pallet, Food & Advice

With Rao’s, you can bring the taste of a homemade pizzeria into your kitchen with every delicious slice.


Shari Mason

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *