15 Best New York Style Pizza Options In Chicago

Last Updated on September 15, 2024 by Shari Mason

Craving a slice in the lively city? **New York’s legendary pizza** awaits. Every bite can whisk you away, bursting with flavors that’ll make you say, “Wow!” Skip the gourmet dinners; go for this iconic, straightforward pizza. It’s like holding a piece of heaven, ready to be enjoyed. **Don’t miss out** when you’re around.

Thankfully, these New York-style pizzas are also widely available in Chicago – perfect for leisurely walking around the iconic neighborhood or during the baseball season. 

Our team has gathered to share some of our favorite places to have the best New York-style pizza in Chicago. Read on.

Top 15 Places To Buy New York-Style Pizzas In Chicago

1. Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe

Average Price: from $20 to over $100

Address: 2434 W Montrose Ave, Chicago, IL, 60618

Why We Love It: In 2022, Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe moved to a bigger place in Montrose after staying in Lincoln Square for over a decade. 

It now has more seating capacity and additional ovens to keep up with the demand for their New York-style pizza with various classic toppings.

They offer pizzas with a crispy crust, fresh and gooey cheese, and tangy sauce.

2. Dimo’s Pizza

Average Price: from $15 to over $40

Address: 3463 N Clark St, Chicago, IL, 60657

Why We Love It: Dimo’s is one of the best places for late-night pizza cravings. You can grab a slice for a quick and easy bite, making it also a good spot in Wrigleyville during the baseball season. 

Moreover, the place offers many vegan toppings, including vegan cheese and marinated tofu or tempeh.

3. Art of Pizza

Average Price: from $16 to over $35

Address: 3033 N Ashland, Chicago, IL, 60657

Why We Love It: Art of Pizza is another great spot for grabbing an entire pie or a few pizza slices. 

Each pizza slice costs around $5 with a buttery but not greasy crust that does not skimp on the toppings. Their Italian beef and deep dish are also worth trying.

4. Coalfire Pizza

Average Price: from $10 to over $30

Address: 1321 West Grand Avenue, Chicago, IL, 60642

Why We Love It: Coalfire pizzas blend New York, Neapolitan, and New Haven styles in a single, thin, and charred dough [1]. 

It has two locations in Chicago that create pizzas using a coal-burning oven that reaches up to 1,500 degrees, leading to customers describing the pies as “forged.”

5. Piece Brewery and Pizzeria

Average Price: from $20 to over $40

Address: 1927 W North Ave, Chicago, IL, 60622

Why We Love It: The freshly-made and hot pizzas here are very affordable, with all styles having oregano, olive oil, and Pecorino-Romano cheese on them. 

But aside from that, this brewery and restaurant opened in 2001 also offers house-made beers to suit any beer lovers or casual drinkers [2].

6. Pizza Metro

Average Price: from $11 to over $40

Address: 1707 W Division St, Chicago, IL, 60622

Why We Love It: Pizza Metro is another pizzeria that opened in 2001 but was temporarily closed after the owner Marco Schiavoni went to Rome. It was reopened later that year, but he started focusing on Italian pastries. 

Thankfully, they brought back their pizzas with fresh ingredients and well-layered flavors.

7. Roots Handmade Pizza

Average Price: from $18 to over $40

Address: 2200 W Lawrence Ave, Chicago, IL, 60625

Why We Love It: Roots is an excellent place for a large group of people, complete with good service and tasty dishes. The crust of the pizzas is thick enough with a slight sweetness. 

“New York-style pizza has slices that are large and wide with a thin crust that is foldable yet crispy. It is traditionally topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, with any extra toppings placed on top of the cheese.”

– Devorah Lev-Tov, Cookbook Editor

8. Gino’s East

Average Price: from $20 to over $30

Address: 162 E Superior St, Chicago, IL, 60611

Why We Love It: Gino’s East has two stores in Chicago, but we went to Magnificent Mile, which has three floors full of graffiti-covered brick walls. It has a comfortable and welcoming ambiance, with weekly shows and an incredible terrace view.

The pizza is one of the most legendary ones in Chicago, featuring a crispy crust and plenty of flavorful toppings.

9. Bonci Pizza

Average Price: from $8 to over $20

Address: 161 N Sangamon St, Chicago, IL, 60607

Why We Love It: Bonci Pizza is a casual neighborhood choice for a pizza where you would be charged by weight instead of a fixed pizza size and cut. This place allows you to experiment and be creative with over 20 topping combinations. 

Note: Bonci Pizza does not accept cash payments.

10. Vito & Nick’s Pizzeria

Average Price: from $18 to over $30

Address: 8433 S Pulaski RD, Chicago, IL, 60652

Why We Love It: Vito & Nick’s Pizzeria is one of the best places in Chicago for pizza. 

The toppings, the thin crust, and the tangy sauce are top-quality, so you would always see this among food blogs. They also offer a tasty Old Style Beer on tap. 

Note: Vito & Nick’s Pizzeria accepts cash-only transactions.

11. Pizzeria Lobo

Average Price: from $11 to over $30

Address: 3000 W Fullerton Ave, Chicago, IL, 60647

Why We Love It: Pizzeria Lobo has a 4000-square-foot patio and a lengthy bar menu that invites customers to feast on their classic New York-style pizzas. 

This concept was developed by Bad Hunter’s former Chef, Dan Snowden, and Heisler Hospitality’s Kevin Heisner and Matt Eisler.

12. Forno Rosso Pizzeria Napoletana

Average Price: from $20 to over $25

Address: 3719 N Harlem Ave, Chicago, IL, 60634

Why We Love It: Forno Rosso Pizzeria is a super fun place to go with friends and family because of its spacious interior. 

You can’t expect a quiet time here since the restaurant has always been crowded with a fun and friendly ambiance. Their pizza has a spectacular flavor with a light and airy crust. 

13. Giordano’s

Average Price: from $20 to over $35

Address: 2010 W Montrose Ave, Chicago, IL, 60625

Why We Love It: Giordano’s is a food chain famous for its Chicago-style deep dish or stuffed pizzas. 

But you can also order a New York-style pizza here, featuring the same toppings, thin crust, and sauce as their well-known stuffed pizza.

14. Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

Average Price: from $12 to over $40

Address: 3333 W Fullerton Ave, Chicago, IL, 60647

Why We Love It: First founded in the early 1970s, Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria features a buttery crust, vine-ripened plum tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese. 

Rudy Malnati’s son founded it – he is considered one of the original creators of deep-dish pizzas in Chicago [3].

Note: This location is for carry-out and delivery only. 

15. Paulie Gee’s Wicker Park

Average Price: from $20 to over $40

Address: 1566 N Damen Ave (N Milwaukee Ave), Chicago, IL, 60622

Why We Love It: Paulie Gee’s Wicker Park is another place you should take advantage of if you’re looking for authentic New York-style pizzas. 

“In the heart of Chicago, a delicious rebellion thrives, as the best New York-style pizza emerges, bringing a taste of the Big Apple to the Windy City.”

– Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

The flavors are perfect. Even if the crust gets slightly overcooked, you can still taste the freshness of the toppings.

FAQs

Key Takeaways

Chicago is best known for their deep-dish style of pizzas that you can eat while sitting down or in one place. 

Although these pizzas are delightfully flavorful, chances are, you might still want to grab a slice and go for a stroll around the iconic neighborhood. 

Fortunately, New York-style pizzas are also widely available in Chicago, and they are one of the best snacks or meals to eat while you’re on the move.

References: 

1. https://www.thrillist.com/amphtml/eat/chicago/best-pizza-in-chicago 
2. https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/illinois/celebrity-owned-restaurant-il/  
3. https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-2009-02-18-0902180055-story.html 
4. https://www.insider.com/guides/kitchen/types-of-pizza