What Kind Of Onion For Tikka Masala

What Kind of Onion for Tikka Masala: Perfecting An Indian Classic

Last Updated on May 19, 2024 by Shari Mason

Choosing the correct variety of onion is crucial when preparing Tikka Masala.

From my cooking experiences, I’ve learned that different onions have different tastes. Some are sweeter, while others are stronger in flavor.

So what kind of onion should you use for Tikka Masala? Let’s find out.

Onion Varieties Commonly Used In Tikka Masala

Slicing Onion
  1. Yellow (or Brown) Onions:
    • These are the most versatile and all-purpose onions [1]. They have an excellent balance of astringency and sweetness in their flavor.
    • For Tikka Masala: Yellow onions are often the top choice for this dish. When sautéed, they caramelize beautifully, releasing their natural sugars and lending a rich sweetness that complements the spices of Tikka Masala.
  2. Red Onions:
    • Red onions are vibrant in color and slightly more pungent than yellow onions. They have a sharpness when raw but mellow out when cooked.
    • For Tikka Masala: While they’re not the traditional first choice, red onions can be used. They lend a deeper color to the gravy and introduce a slightly different flavor profile.
  3. White Onions:
    • These onions have a milder flavor and are crisper in texture. They’re often used in Mexican cuisine and salads due to their gentle taste.
    • Tikka Masala is not the most common choice, but it can be used if one desires a subtler onion presence in the dish. Their mild nature might not offer the same richness as yellow or red onions, but they blend well.
  4. Sweet Onions (like Vidalia or Walla Walla):
    • As the name suggests, these onions are sweeter and have a higher water content. They’re great for frying or using in dishes where a pronounced sweetness is desired.
    • For Tikka Masala: They can be used for a unique twist, bringing out an enhanced sweetness in the gravy, but might make the dish a tad sweeter than traditional versions.

“Life is like an onion: you peel off layer after layer, and then you find nothing in it.”

– James Huneker, American Music Critic


Why Are Onions Important In Tikka Masala?

Tikka Masala

In Tikka Masala, onions are indispensable, laying the foundation for the dish’s deep, aromatic flavor. 

Serving as a base, onions, when sautéed or caramelized, release natural sugars that harmonize with the symphony of spices, providing sweetness and body to the gravy. 

Their transformation during the cooking process, from a raw pungency to a mellow richness, gives Tikka Masala [2] its characteristic depth, making them a cornerstone in achieving the perfect balance of flavors in this beloved Indian delicacy.

“In the symphony of Tikka Masala, every onion has its note; it’s the harmony of sweetness and depth that sets the melody right.” – Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

How Should The Onions Be Prepared?

  1. Selection:
    • Choose firm onions with no soft spots or visible mold. The skin should be dry and papery.
  2. Peeling:
    • Remove the top and root ends with a sharp knife.
    • Make a shallow slit from top to bottom and peel away the outer layer.
  3. Washing:
    • It’s usually unnecessary to wash onions. However, if they’ve been exposed to dirt or contaminants, rinse them briefly under cool water after peeling.
  4. Chopping or Grating:
    • Finely Chopped: This is the most common preparation for Tikka Masala. Use a sharp knife to chop the onions finely. This helps them meld into the sauce, giving it a thick consistency and rich flavor.
    • Grated: Grating onions produces a pulp that blends smoothly into the gravy, ensuring no chunks. This method is beneficial if you want a velvety texture for your Tikka Masala.
  5. Sautéing:
    • Heat oil or ghee (clarified butter) in a pan over medium heat.
    • Add the prepared onions and stir frequently. The goal is to sweat the onions until they turn translucent, allowing them to caramelize slightly enhancing their sweetness. This crucial step builds the foundation of the gravy’s flavor.
  6. Blending (Optional):
    • In some recipes, after sautéing with tomatoes and spices, the mixture is blended to achieve a smoother gravy. If you prefer a silkier texture without bits of onion, use a blender or immersion blender to process the mix until smooth.


u003cstrongu003eIs red onion sweeter than yellow onion?u003c/strongu003e

No, yellow onions are generally sweeter than red onions. Red onions have a sharper, more intense flavor when raw.

u003cstrongu003eWhat veggies go well with tikka masala?u003c/strongu003e

Bell peppers, cauliflower, peas, potatoes, and green beans pair well with Tikka Masala.

In Conclusion

Choosing the right onion for Tikka Masala can significantly affect the dish’s taste and texture. Most chefs and home cooks lean towards using yellow onions because they offer a good balance of sweetness and flavor, especially when cooked down and caramelized. 

These onions blend well with the savory spices and create a smooth, rich base for the sauce. But that’s not to say you can’t experiment with red or white onions. 

Red onions can give the dish a deeper color and a unique taste, while white onions offer a milder flavor. No matter which onion you pick, it’s all about how you prepare and cook it. 

The onion, often overlooked, is a critical player in making Tikka Masala a favorite for many, so it’s worth taking the time to choose and use it well.


Shari Mason

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *