5 Substitutes For Xanthan Gum In Ice Cream: Revealed

Last Updated on August 16, 2024 by Shari Mason

Creating ice cream usually involves a good measure of creativity, but there can be instances where you find yourself without an essential ingredient, such as xanthan gum, in your kitchen. This is a problem I’ve come across when trying to craft ice cream at home.

Whether due to dietary constraints, personal preferences, or simple pantry shortages, seeking a substitute for xanthan gum in ice cream recipes is important. 

Let’s dive into the world of alternative ingredients that can deliver comparable results without compromising the ice cream’s luscious consistency.

5 Substitutes For Xanthum Gum In Ice Cream

1. Guar Gum

A reliable alternative to xanthan gum [1], guar gum is extracted from the guar bean and boasts thickening and stabilizing properties.

When used as a substitute, it can help create a smooth texture in ice cream, preventing the formation of ice crystals. 

Use it in a similar quantity as you would xanthan gum, keeping in mind that a little goes a long way. Be cautious not to overuse it, as excessive guar gum can result in a slimy texture. 

Blend it into your ice cream base, and watch as it works its magic to ensure a velvety consistency in your frozen delight.

Also Read:

• How Much Salt Is In Ice Cream?
• How To Thicken Store-Bought Frosting?
• How To Use Xanthum Gum To Thicken Soup?
• How Long Does Homemade Ice Cream Last In Freezer?
• What Kind Of Gelatin Does Rice Krispies Have?

2. Locust Bean Gum (Carob Bean Gum)

Extracted from the seeds of the carob tree, locust bean gum offers a natural alternative to xanthan gum in ice cream recipes. 

Its ability to thicken and stabilize can help achieve that desired creamy texture while preventing unwanted ice crystal formation. 

“A boxer’s diet should be low in fat, protein, and sugar. Therefore you should eat plenty of lean meat, milk, leafy vegetables, and fresh fruit and ice cream for sugar.”

– Gene Tunney, American Professional Boxer

When using locust bean gum as a substitute, consider combining it with other gums or thickeners to achieve optimal results. 

Its neutral taste makes it an adaptable choice, seamlessly blending into your ice cream base and ensuring a delightful spoonful of smoothness in every bite.

3. Agar-Agar

For those seeking a plant-based alternative to xanthan gum, agar-agar [2] steps up as a worthy contender. 

Derived from seaweed, agar-agar offers a unique gelling property that can contribute to the luscious consistency of ice cream. 

While it’s more gel-like, it can still help prevent ice crystals and deliver a silky mouthfeel. Remember that a little goes a long way when substituting agar-agar for xanthan gum. 

Experiment with small amounts to strike the perfect balance, allowing your ice cream to embody the same velvety texture you crave.

4. Gelatin

Although not vegan, gelatin is a traditional substitute for xanthan gum in ice cream. Derived from animal collagen, gelatin brings a unique quality to the table by imparting a creamy texture to frozen treats. 

Dissolve gelatin in a warm liquid before adding it to your ice cream base, ensuring it blends seamlessly.

While it may not be suitable for all dietary preferences, gelatin can still offer that desired smoothness and stability to your homemade ice cream. 

Just be mindful of its animal-based origin and adjust quantities based on your recipe to achieve the desired consistency.

5. Cornstarch

A pantry staple, cornstarch is a versatile thickening agent that can also substitute for xanthan gum in ice cream recipes.

While it doesn’t provide the same gelling properties, it can still contribute to achieving a creamy consistency. 

“In the world of ice cream, xanthan gum is but one dance step in the waltz of creaminess; many partners await to take its place.”

– Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

To use cornstarch as a substitute, create a slurry by mixing it with a cold liquid from your ice cream base. Gradually incorporate the slurry into the heated base, stirring constantly until it thickens. 

Cornstarch might not prevent ice crystals as effectively as xanthan gum, so consider using it with other stabilizers for optimal results.

FAQs

Key Takeaways

Navigating the world of ice cream-making without xanthan gum opens up a realm of alternative possibilities. 

Whether embracing plant-based options like guar gum and locust bean gum, experimenting with agar-agar’s gelling properties, or even considering traditional thickeners like gelatin and cornstarch, each substitute brings unique texture and qualities to the frozen dessert. 

Remember that while these alternatives can maintain the smoothness and stability of your ice cream, adjusting quantities and combinations may be necessary to achieve the desired results. 

Embrace the versatility and creativity of these substitutes as you continue to churn out delightful frozen treats.

References:

1. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/xanthan-gum
2. https://www.thespruceeats.com/what-is-agar-agar-p2-1000960