Jimmy John’s Vito vs Italian Night Club: A Sub Showdown

Last Updated on September 16, 2024 by Shari Mason

Loving sandwiches might leave you in a tasty pickle at Jimmy John’s, torn between the Vito or the Italian Night Club.

It’s a tough choice but one that’s worth exploring. The Vito promised a mouthful of savory salami, while the Italian Night Club boasted layers of ham and provolone.

Today, I’ll share my firsthand experience comparing these two tasty options. Keep reading. 

Jimmy John’s Sandwich Showdown: Vito vs Italian Night Club

The Vito boasts hand-sliced salami, capicola, and provolone cheese. 

Adding oil, vinegar, onions, oregano-basil [1], lettuce, and tomato to their famous French bread sets it apart. It’s a flavorful choice but leans towards a lighter Italian sub.

“Trying to be happy by accumulating possessions is like trying to satisfy hunger by taping sandwiches all over your body”

– George Carlin, American Comedian and Actor

On the other hand, the Italian Night Club features salami, capicola, ham, provolone cheese, mayo, oil & vinegar, and Italian seasoning. 

Calorie-wise, it ranges from 580 to 1860 calories, with the Unwich Lettuce Wrap being the lightest and the Giant French Bread option the heaviest.

But what’s the distinction between Jimmy John’s Club Tuna and Totally Tuna?

In-Depth Comparison Table Guide

Aspect	Vito Sub Sandwich	Italian Night Club
Description	Hand-sliced salami, capicola, provolone cheese, oil, vinegar, onions, oregano-basil, lettuce, and tomato on French bread	Salami, capicola, ham, provolone cheese, mayo, oil & vinegar, Italian seasoning on bread
Caloric Range	560 to 1360 calories, with Unwich being the lightest and Giant French Bread the heaviest	580 to 1860 calories, with Unwich Lettuce Wrap the lightest and Giant French Bread the heaviest
Taste and Flavor Profiles	Offers a lighter Italian sub with a medley of flavors from deli meats. Bread is flavorful but slightly tough and crusty. Mayo-based sauce with oregano basil.	Crispy and chewy French bread is the ideal sub sandwich base. Meats, cheese, and veggies harmonize well with no overpowering flavors.
Nutritional Information:	Higher carbs, fat, protein, and overall calories than Vito. Customizable for a healthier option, like the “Unwich”	Lower in carbs, fat, protein, and calories. Also customizable as an “Unwich.” High in sodium, so make informed choices for balance.
Popularity	Known for its harmonious blend of Jimmy John’s offerings, with intense yet balanced flavors. Salami, capicola, and provolone cheese shine independently.	Perfect for late-night cravings, with bold ingredients like salami, capicola, and smoked ham creating a satisfying experience without overpowering each other.
Price Point	Starts at $7.49 for a Solo Regular and goes up to $18.09 for a Combo Regular	Begins at $9.09 for a Solo Regular and extends to $21.29 for a Combo Regular. Offers a range of sizes and combinations to fit different budgets.

What Sets Them Apart

Taste and Flavor Profiles

As someone who loves exploring different sandwiches, the Italian Night Club offers a decent taste with a medley of flavors from its various deli meats. 

However, I found the bread a tad tough and crusty. The sauce, a mayo blend with oregano basil, only stood out a little as the meat took the spotlight.

Conversely, Vito’s French bread, freshly baked daily, provides the perfect sub sandwich base. The whole wheat option adds a healthier touch. 

Crispy on the outside and chewy inside, it’s ideal for on-the-go munching. The meats, cheese, and veggies harmonize, with no one overpowering the others.

But what’s the distinction between Jimmy John’s Slims and regular?

Nutritional Information

Here’s a comparison of the nutritional content between Jimmy John’s Italian Night Unwich and the Vito sub sandwich:

Nutrient	Italian Night Club	Vito Sub Sandwich
Total Carbohydrates (g)	72	60
Net Carbohydrates (g)	67	56
Total Fat (g)	46	32
Protein (g)	48	30
Calories	930	644

The Italian Night Club has higher carbs, fat, protein, and overall calories than the Vito. However, both sandwiches can be customized to your preferences. 

For a healthier option, consider ordering either sandwich’s “Unwich” version to reduce carb intake. 

Remember that the meat in both sandwiches is high in sodium, so make informed choices when customizing for a balanced meal.

Popularity

In the popularity contest, the Vito sandwich takes the lead. It’s like a harmonious blend of everything Jimmy John’s offers without overwhelming your taste buds. 

What sets it apart is its intense yet balanced flavor profile. The combination of salami [2], capicola, and provolone cheese stands out, and these meats shine independently.

“The Vito is the sandwich for those who appreciate the finer subtleties of flavor, while the Italian Night Club packs a punch that’s perfect for hearty cravings.”

– Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

Now, let’s talk about the Italian Night Club. This sandwich is perfect for those late-night cravings after a night out. 

Packed with bold ingredients like salami, capicola, and smoked ham, it might seem like a lot of meat, but the flavors play together nicely, creating a satisfying experience without one overpowering the others.

Check out the differences between Whopper and Whopper Jr. here.

Price Point

Regarding price, both the Vito and the Italian Night Club offer a range of options to fit different budgets. 

The Vito starts at $7.49 for a Solo Regular and goes up to $18.09 for a Combo Regular. 

On the other hand, the Italian Night Club begins at $9.09 for a Solo Regular and extends to $21.29 for a Combo Regular.

While the Vito generally offers a slightly lower starting price, the Italian Night Club provides more expensive options at the high end. 

Your choice depends on your appetite and budget, with both sandwiches offering a variety of sizes and combinations to cater to your preferences.

Also Read: How Does Jimmy John’s Differ From Subway?

FAQs

On A Final Note

Jimmy John’s Vito and Italian Night Club sandwiches offer distinct experiences. 

The Vito wins in the popularity department due to its well-balanced and delightful taste, highlighted by the combination of salami, capicola, and provolone cheese. 

When it comes to flavor profiles, the Vito again excels, delivering intense yet harmonious flavors. 

In contrast, while decent, the Italian Night Club struggles with its tougher bread and less pronounced sauce. 

Regarding nutritional information, the Italian Night Club boasts higher carbs, fat, protein, and overall calories than the Vito. Still, both sandwiches can be customized for a healthier option. 

Finally, regarding price point, the Vito starts at a slightly lower price, making it a more budget-friendly choice. 

Your preference between these two delectable options will depend on your taste, dietary considerations, and budget constraints. 

References:

1. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/266259
2. https://www.livestrong.com/article/377229-is-salami-healthy/