Costco Lobster Tails Review

Costco Lobster Tails Review: Complete Guide (Updated)

Last Updated on June 16, 2024 by Shari Mason

Costco’s lobster tails are a tasty and budget-friendly way to savor **lobster** without spending too much.

It’s easy to get carried away with all the fantastic things found at Costco, but their Lobster Tails may come in handy for saving some pennies on dinner one night. 

Today, we will share our honest Costco lobster tails review with you so that you know whether or not they are worth buying.

Costco Lobster Tails Honest Review 

Costco Lobster Tails

Location & Availability

Rating: 7/10

Costco lobster tails are always available online. We didn’t have a hard time processing our orders. Online purchases are a big help, especially for those who don’t have time to shop.

But, because you’ll receive the package via delivery services, the ETA is sometimes inaccurate. So you better order ahead of time.


Price Point 

Rating: 7/10

The cost at Costco includes delivery and shipping. There are three to four lobster tails in each pound. We received about 21 lobster tails. 

However, almost $300 looks incredibly pricey, but it’s no wonder that lobster tails are pricey.

Read: How Long After A Lobster Dies Can You Eat It?

Taste & Texture

 Rating: 9/10

They didn’t taste or smell fishy, even if it’s not fresh and frozen, which is vital to us. They were juicy, salty, savory, and just plain delicious. 

They were also relatively simple to remove from the shell. We ordered lobster tail plain and lobster tail with melted butter. They were both delicious.

Packaging & Convenience

Rating: 5/10

Regarding convenience, lobster tails were packaged in one open bag inside a large box with a styrofoam cooler. 

The dry ice in the cooler with the lobster tails was almost gone when the box was delivered.

However, cooking lobster tail is not that easy to cook because of the tendency of the meat to stick to the shell, making it hard to remove.

Nutritional Facts

Rating: 10/10

Less than 100 calories per lobster tail, 14 grams of protein, less than 1 gram of fat, and 0 grams of carbs make lobster tails calorie-efficient. 

You will have a lot more calories and fat if you add oil or butter.

Types of Lobster Tails

Lobster Tails on a Wooden Chopping Board

Warm Water from Brazil

Warm Water Lobster Tails from Brazil are known to have tender and tasty meat. This is because meat from lobster tails that have lived in a warm environment is soft and delicious. 

These smooth, speckled, greenish-colored warm water lobster tails, often known as spiny lobsters, are found amid rocks, on reefs, and in eelgrass beds. [1] 

Cold Water from the USA

The American lobster often called the Maine or Canadian lobster, is said to be the most well-liked of all the lobster species. It is colorful and has large claws.

“Food brings people together on many different levels. It’s the nourishment of the soul and body; it’s true love.”

– Giada De Laurentiis, Italian American Chef

Because of the extreme cold, the meat in cold-water lobster is significantly firmer and cooks into tenderness. It has a sweet, subtle fish taste. 

Difference Between Warm Water & Cold Water Lobster Tails  

The warm-water lobster is less sweet and delicate than the cold-water lobster. Warm-water lobster has firmer meat and a stronger seafood flavor than cold-water lobster tails.

Their flavors which are undoubtedly both delicious and enjoyable, also have a difference. Cold-water lobsters are less tasty than lobsters raised in warm climates. [2] 

How to Cook Costco Lobster Tails

After purchasing, you can grill, bake, broil, steam, boil, bake, or even smoke lobster tails.

The easiest way to prevent the lobster tails from clinging to the shell if you’re unsure which procedure to use is to boil them.

After thawing your lobster tail, stick a skewer to them, pour your preferred ingredients into the tails, and boil them together for 10-13 minutes (depending on tail sizes). 


u003cstrongu003eAre the lobster tails at Costco good?u003c/strongu003e

Yes, lobster tails at Costco are excellent and tasty despite being frozen and not so fresh because of the delivery duration.

u003cstrongu003eHow many lobster tails come in a Costco box?u003c/strongu003e

You can get 21 lobster tails in a box from Costco when you order online. These were packed in food-grade plastic surrounded with ice to keep the lobster tails fresh while shipping.

u003cstrongu003eAre frozen lobster tails as good as fresh ones?u003c/strongu003e

Yes, frozen lobsters are as good as fresh ones. There is a little difference in textures because fresh lobsters were tender, but as for the taste, both were nearly identical.

u003cstrongu003eShould I thaw frozen lobster tails before cooking?u003c/strongu003e

Yes, you should thaw frozen lobster in the fridge overnight before cooking them to avoid firm meat and get the best results in taste and texture.

Final Thoughts

Lobster tails at Costco are excellent and delicious. The shipping was fast, and the packaging was safe. 

In terms of prices, Costco Lobster Tails were expensive compared to the market. 

However, we might order again at Costco for special occasions because their lobsters are perfect for celebrations or any particular day.


Shari Mason

2 thoughts on “Costco Lobster Tails Review: Complete Guide (Updated)”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *