Can You Use Regular Cucumbers For Pickling

Can You Use Regular Cucumbers For Pickling?

Last Updated on July 17, 2024 by Shari Mason

Throughout my culinary journey as a cooking enthusiast, I’ve had several thrilling experiences with the art of pickling.

One common question that often comes up is whether you can use regular cucumbers for pickling. Luckily, I found the answer. Here’s what I found out.

Is It Okay To Use Regular Cucumbers For Pickling? 

Harvesting Cucumber

Yes, using regular cucumbers [1] for pickling is terrific! While they may not possess the same ideal qualities as pickling cucumbers, such as thin skins and minimal seeds, regular cucumbers can still be transformed into tasty pickles with extra care. 

“Cucumber reminds me of my mother making me eat sprouts.”

– Mark Lawrenson, Former Football Player

Just ensure that the cucumbers you choose are fresh and firm.

While the texture and flavor may differ slightly from traditional pickling cucumbers, regular cucumbers offer a unique twist to your pickling creations.  

Read: Cava Cucumber Mint Lime Recipe

What Makes A Cucumber Suitable For Pickling?

  1. Size: Pickling cucumbers are typically smaller in size compared to regular cucumbers. Their smaller size allows them to absorb the pickling brine more effectively, producing a balanced flavor and texture.
  2. Texture: Pickling cucumbers have a firm and crisp texture, which is highly desirable in pickles. Their texture ensures that the cucumbers retain their crunchiness even after pickling.
  3. Thin Skin: Pickling cucumbers have thin, tender skins and are easier to bite into. The thin skin also allows the flavors of the pickling brine to penetrate the cucumber more efficiently.
  4. Few Seeds: Pickling cucumbers tend to have fewer seeds than regular cucumbers. This attribute contributes to a smoother and more enjoyable eating experience with pickles.

How Should You Prepare Regular Cucumbers For Pickling?

Pickled Cucumbers on a Jar
  1. Wash: Thoroughly wash the regular cucumbers to remove any dirt or wax that may be present on the skin.
  2. Trim: Trim off the ends of the cucumbers. Cut off a small slice from both the stem and blossom ends.
  3. Slice: Slice the cucumbers to your desired thickness. You can opt for thin or thick slices or even experiment with cuts like spears or chips for added variety.
  4. Salt: Sprinkle salt over the sliced cucumbers and let them sit for 1-2 hours. This process, known as salting, helps draw out excess moisture from the cucumbers and can improve their crunchiness.
  5. Rinse: After salting, rinse the cucumbers with cold water to remove the salt and any excess moisture. This step is essential to ensure the pickling brine is balanced.
  6. Pack: Pack the cucumber slices tightly into clean, sterilized jars or containers, leaving some headspace at the top.
  7. Brine: Prepare a pickling brine using vinegar [2], water, sugar, salt, and desired spices or herbs. Heat the brine until the sugar and salt dissolve completely.
  8. Pour: Carefully pour the hot pickling brine over the cucumber slices, ensuring that they are fully submerged. Leave a small gap at the top of the jar to allow for expansion during the pickling process.
  9. Seal: Securely seal the jars with lids or covers.
  10. Pickle: Place the jars in the refrigerator or follow a suitable pickling method (such as water bath canning) according to a reliable recipe. The pickles will need some time to develop their flavor, so be patient and let them pickle for the recommended duration.


Can Regular Cucumbers Be Made Crunchy Like Pickling Cucumbers?

While regular cucumbers may not naturally possess the same inherent crunchiness as pickling cucumbers, there are ways to enhance their texture and make them crunchy like their pickling counterparts. 

One effective method is to salt the sliced regular cucumbers and let them sit for a few hours. This process, known as salting, helps draw out excess moisture from the cucumbers, resulting in a firmer texture. 

“Embrace the unconventional, for in the world of pickling, even regular cucumbers can transform into extraordinary delights, infused with the flavors of creativity and the joy of experimentation.”

– Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

Additionally, you can briefly experiment with soaking the cucumber slices in an ice water bath before pickling. This technique can help crisp up the cucumbers and create a satisfying crunch in the last pickles. 


u003cstrongu003eDoes it matter what kind of cucumbers are for pickles?u003c/strongu003e

No, it doesn’t matter what kind of cucumbers you use for pickles as long as they are fresh and firm.

u003cstrongu003eDo cucumbers need to be soaked before pickling?u003c/strongu003e

Soaking cucumbers before pickling is unnecessary, but it can help improve their texture and crispiness.

Key Takeaways

You can use regular cucumbers for pickling. While they may not possess the same ideal characteristics as pickling cucumbers, regular cucumbers can still be transformed into delicious pickles with extra care. 

By selecting fresh and firm cucumbers, adjusting the preparation techniques, and experimenting with flavors, you can embark on a pickling adventure that showcases the versatility and creativity of regular cucumbers. 

So, don’t hesitate to embrace these vibrant green vegetables and dive into the world of homemade pickles. Happy pickling.


Shari Mason

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *