Can I Make Jello Pudding With Oat Milk

Can I Make Jello Pudding with Oat Milk? Dessert Guide

Last Updated on June 18, 2024 by Shari Mason

The call for substitutes for conventional ingredients is on the rise. Often, I am asked about substituting regular milk with oat milk, notably in classic recipes such as Jello pudding.

From personal trials in my kitchen, let’s find out if you can make Jello pudding with oat milk. Read on.

Is Oat Milk A Suitable Replacement For Dairy In Jello Pudding?

Pouring Jello Instant Pudding on a Bowl of Milk

Oat milk [1] can effectively replace dairy in Jello pudding, ensuring a delectable outcome with the proper consistency. The key to achieving that perfect set lies in maintaining the correct ratios. 

While oat milk boasts a creamy texture akin to regular milk, it’s crucial to be mindful of measurements to ensure the pudding sets as desired. 

“I love the smell of a real Christmas tree – also, my mum’s Christmas pudding with brandy sauce.”

– Mallory Jansen, Australian Actress

By doing so, pudding enthusiasts can savor a dairy-free version that retains the beloved creamy consistency of the classic dish.

Related Articles:

Does Oat Milk Alter The Taste Of The Pudding?

Yes, incorporating oat milk into your Jello pudding can introduce a subtle difference in flavor.

Oat milk carries a naturally sweet, mild, and slightly nutty undertone, which can subtly influence the overall taste of the pudding [2]. 

The oat-infused variant might add richness and depth for those familiar with the traditional dairy-based pudding. 

While many find this nuanced flavor enjoyable, lending a modern twist to the classic, others might notice and prefer the familiar taste of dairy.

The personal palate, as always, plays a pivotal role in determining one’s preference.

Will The Pudding Set Properly With Oat Milk?

Using oat milk in Jello pudding can yield a proper set, but it’s essential to be mindful of the ratios.

Oat milk’s consistency is generally thicker than standard milk, and its starch content can influence the pudding’s texture. 

When substituted in a 1:1 ratio for dairy milk, the pudding might be less firm than regular milk.

However, you can achieve the desired consistency by slightly reducing the amount of oat milk or increasing the setting agent’s quantity. 

It’s always a good idea to start with the manufacturer’s recommended amount and adjust based on personal preferences and desired texture.

Are All Oat Milk Brands Equally Effective In Pudding?

Glass of Milk

Not all oat milk brands are created equal, especially when making pudding. The consistency, flavor, and ingredient composition can vary widely among brands. 

Some oat milk might be creamier with a higher fat content, while others might be more watery. Adding sugars, stabilizers, or other additives can also influence how the pudding sets and tastes. 

“In the dance of flavors, oat milk waltzes with Jello pudding to create a harmony both unique and delightful.”

– Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

When opting to use oat milk for pudding, it’s advisable to choose a brand known for its richer texture and minimal additives.

However, experimentation might be necessary to determine which brand works best for your specific pudding needs.

Any Tips For Perfecting Oat Milk Jello Pudding?

  1. Richness Matters: Opt for a full-bodied, creamy oat milk rather than a watery one. This ensures a luscious texture in your pudding.
  2. Watch Ratios: Oat milk might require slightly different quantities than dairy milk. Start with the recommended amount and adjust as needed.
  3. Stir Constantly: To prevent lumping or sticking to the pot, continuously stir the mixture while it’s heating.
  4. Temperature Check: Oat milk can burn or stick faster than regular milk. Ensure you’re cooking on medium to low heat and monitor closely.
  5. Taste Test: Since oat milk has a distinct flavor, you should adjust the sweetness or add more vanilla or other flavorings.
  6. Setting Time: Oat milk-based pudding may take slightly longer to set than dairy-based ones. Be patient and let it chill adequately.
  7. Add Thickeners if Needed: Add a little cornstarch or another thickener if your pudding is too runny.
  8. Avoid Overcooking: Overcooking can lead to a gummy texture. Cook just until it reaches the desired consistency.
  9. Chill Thoroughly: Allow the pudding to cool at room temperature before transferring it to the fridge. This helps in achieving the perfect consistency.
  10. Experiment with Flavors: Oat milk can complement various flavors. Don’t hesitate to experiment with additions like cinnamon, nutmeg, or even chocolate.


u003cstrongu003eWhy won’t my pudding set with oat milk?u003c/strongu003e

Your pudding might not be set with oat milk due to its lower protein and fat content than dairy milk, affecting the thickening process. u003cbru003eu003cbru003eAdjusting the ratio or adding thickeners can help achieve the desired consistency.

u003cstrongu003eWill Jello pudding set with almond milk?u003c/strongu003e

Due to its lower protein content, Jello pudding may not set as firmly with almond milk as with dairy milk. u003cbru003eu003cbru003eHowever, you can achieve a better consistency by reducing the amount of almond milk or adding a thickener.

Key Takeaways

Making Jello pudding with oat milk is a delightful twist for those seeking dairy-free alternatives. 

While oat milk’s unique flavor and consistency might slightly alter the traditional taste and texture of the pudding, the results can still be creamy and enjoyable.

Pay attention to the milk-to-powder ratio and make slight adjustments for the perfect set. 

By embracing oat milk, not only do you cater to dietary restrictions, but you also introduce a new dimension of flavor to a classic treat. Experiment, adjust, and savor the delightful union of Jello pudding and oat milk.


Shari Mason

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *