Bread Pudding vs French Toast Casserole: Which is Better?

Last Updated on September 15, 2024 by Shari Mason

Cooking at home feels like embarking on a yummy adventure. **Trying out new recipes and combining different tastes** always stays exciting.

Today, I want to share with you my love for bread-based desserts—specifically, bread pudding and French toast casserole.

Though they both showcase the deliciousness of bread, these delightful treats possess their own unique characteristics that set them apart. Read on to find out.

French Toast Casserole & Bread Pudding Main Differences

Bread pudding is made with stale or day-old bread, resulting in a moist and custard-like texture.

It is soaked in a custard mixture and baked until set and golden. With its rich and often spiced flavor, bread pudding is typically served with sauce or syrup.

On the other hand, French toast casserole uses fresh or slightly stale bread, creating a soft and slightly crispy texture. The bread is dipped in a custard mixture and baked until crispy and golden.

“Two worlds born from humble bread: custard oasis, crispy symphony. Bread pudding, velvety; French toast casserole, sweet and crispy.”

Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

French toast casserole offers a sweet and often flavored experience and is served with toppings and syrup.

Additionally, both desserts allow for variation, with bread pudding featuring various add-ins and French toast casserole incorporating different fillings.

Read:

• What To Do With Leftover French Toast Batter?
• Can I Make Jello Pudding With Oat Milk?
• Is It Better To Boil Or Bake Sweet Potatoes For Casserole?

A Closer Look

	Bread Pudding	French Toast Casserole
Bread	Stale or day-old bread	Fresh or slightly stale bread
Texture	Moist and custard-like	Soft and slightly crispy
Soaking	Soaked in custard mixture	Dipped in custard mixture
Baking	Baked until set and golden	Baked until crispy and golden
Flavor	Rich and often spiced	Sweet and often flavored
Serving	Served with sauce or syrup	Served with toppings and syrup
Variation	Can be made with various add-ins	Can incorporate different fillings

What Is Bread Pudding?

Bread pudding [1] is a classic dessert made by soaking bread in eggs, milk, sugar, and other flavorings, such as cinnamon, vanilla, or nutmeg.

The mixture is baked in the oven until the bread is soft and custardy and a golden-brown crust forms. 

Bread pudding can be served warm or cold and is often topped with whipped cream, ice cream, or a sweet sauce, such as caramel or bourbon sauce. It is a delicious and comforting dessert for cold winter nights or special occasions. 

Bread pudding can also be made with various breads, such as brioche, croissants, or challah, giving it a unique flavor and texture.

What Is French Toast Casserole?

French toast casserole [2] is a baked dish made by layering slices of bread in a casserole dish and soaking them in an egg and milk mixture, just like traditional French toast. 

The bread is often flavored with cinnamon, nutmeg, or other spices and can be topped with maple syrup, fruit, or whipped cream.

“My secret indulgent food is dessert. I have an incredible sweet tooth – chocolate pudding with vanilla ice cream or trifle and pavlova. I do love dessert.”

– Deborra-Lee Furness, Australian Actress

French toast casserole is an excellent option for serving a crowd, as it can be prepared and baked in the oven just before serving. 

It is a delicious and comforting breakfast or brunch for holidays or special occasions.

French toast casserole can be made with any bread, from regular white bread to more substantial bread like brioche or challah, giving it a more decadent and indulgent flavor.

Which One Is Healthier? 

Both bread pudding and French toast casserole are not considered healthy desserts as they are high in calories and sugar. However, there are some ways to make them healthier. 

Some options to make these dishes healthier are using whole grain bread instead of white bread, reducing the sugar in the custard mixture, and serving with fresh fruit instead of syrup or whipped cream. 

Ultimately, it is up to personal preferences and dietary needs to determine a better fit.

How To Serve Bread Pudding & French Toast Casserole?

1. Toppings: Bread pudding can be served with various toppings, such as whipped cream, ice cream, caramel sauce, or fresh fruit. French toast casserole can be served with maple syrup, powdered sugar, fresh berries, or whipped cream.
2. Warm or cold: Bread pudding and French toast casserole can be served warm or cold, depending on personal preference. Warm bread pudding is especially comforting on a cold winter’s day.
3. Individual servings: Bread pudding and French toast casserole can be baked and served in individual ramekins for a more elegant presentation.
4. Accompaniments: Bread pudding and French toast casserole can be served with various accompaniments, such as coffee, tea, or orange juice, to complete the breakfast or brunch experience.
5. Layering: French toast casserole can be layered with cream cheese, Nutella, or other ingredients for added flavor and texture.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

Bread pudding and French toast casserole are two delicious and comforting desserts with bread as their main ingredient. While they share some similarities, such as using eggs, milk, and spices, they differ in texture, bread type, preparation, toppings, and occasion. 

Ultimately, whether to make bread pudding or French toast casserole will depend on personal preference, dietary needs, and the occasion. 

Both dishes can be made healthier by using whole grain bread and reducing the amount of sugar, and they can be served in various ways, including with sweet sauces or fresh fruit. 

Whatever your choice, bread pudding and French toast casserole will satisfy any sweet tooth and make a delicious addition to your breakfast or brunch spread.

References:

1. https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1012636-simple-bread-pudding
2. https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/240502/easy-french-toast-casserole/