10 Best Store-Bought Burger Seasonings To Try

Last Updated on September 14, 2024 by Shari Mason

Even master chefs with the best tools might cook a so-so burger if they skip the **perfect seasoning mix.**

It’s not just about what makes up the seasoning mix; it’s the right proportions that make any burger flavorful. 

If you plan to prepare burgers for your next picnic, here is our list of the best store-bought burger seasonings so you don’t have to make it from scratch. 

Top 10 Store-Bought Burger Seasonings

10. Lawry’s Seasoned Salt

Average Price: around $2.94/8oz 

Why We Love It: Lawry’s Seasoned Salt is one of the most popular burger seasoning mixes for its consistency. 

We like this traditional seasoning mix due to its combination of spices and herbs complementing the unique combo of salt and sugar.

Aside from burgers, we suggest you try Lawry’s for making dry rub or marinades. 

Its simple and balanced ingredients make it one of the most versatile seasoning mixes available.

9. McCormick Grill Mates Hamburger Seasoning

Average Price: around $21.73/24oz

Why We Love It: Another excellent example of a versatile and simple burger seasoning is McCormick’s Grill Mates. 

We like this blend of seasoned salt and spices that can be used for various applications. 

The edge of McCormick’s blend is that it has a little more heat, which is not as noticeable on a burger but very enjoyable in potato or any poultry dishes.

8. Steak N’ Shake Fry N’ Steakburger Seasoning

Average Price: around $13.98/2-pack 

Why We Love It: From the food chain Steak N’ Shake, their seasoning is one of the main reasons their burgers have attracted customers until today. 

This classic seasoning from Steak N’ Shake only contains a limited amount of spices. But it truly brings a flavorsome taste to burgers. 

If you love the taste of this Steak n’ Shake but don’t live near one of its locations, you need to buy their seasoning mix to bring it home. 

7. Weber Blazin’ Burger Seasoning

Average Price: around $3.99/2.75oz

Why We Love It: Weber is a well-known brand that sells grills. So it’s no surprise that this brand has created its own blend of spices to season different meats for optimal results. 

Actually, this is the most unique option on this list as it has a variety of peppers, such as bell peppers, jalapenos, and chili peppers, adding a slight heat to your burger. 

Evened out by other flavors, this spice still maintains its original flavor. The hint of brown sugar also adds a savory and sweet flavor to this seasoning mix.

6. Famous Dave’s Steak & Burger Seasoning

Average Price: around $14.50/2-pack 

Why We Love It: Famous Dave’s signature burger seasoning is the same that is trademark of this food chain. 

Their flavorful burger seasoning mix comprises unique ingredients, including celery seed extract, natural smoke flavoring, and lemon juice. 

Parsley, garlic powder, salt, sugar, and dehydrated garlic are also present, contributing to the overall flavor of this seasoning mix. 

Try it in your homemade burgers, and you’ll leave wanting more bites. 

Read: How To Cook Frozen White Castle Burgers?

5. St Elmo Steakhouse World Famous Seasoning

Average Price: around $11.89/13oz

Why We Love It: Since 1902, St Elmo’s Steakhouse has been known for its famous seasoning blend. 

So, we tried it, and we can say that although it’s simple, it is super balanced—ideal for any type of food. 

The St. Elmo’s burger seasoning blend doesn’t contain any spices. Instead, it contains various ingredients such as sea salt, celery, onion, black peppercorns, paprika, and garlic.

4. McCormick Grill Mates Montreal Steak Seasoning

Average Price: around $14.47/29oz 

Why We Love It: McCormick Montreal steak seasoning blend utilizes a few unique ingredients to create a unique flavor, including a considerable amount of black pepper and garlic.

“The secret (to burgers) is in the blend.”

— Gordon Ramsay, British Chef 

We like the black pepper and garlic blend, which adds a powerful flavor to grilled meat, such as burgers and steak. 

Although paprika extract is mainly used for color, it also brings flavor and doesn’t contain sugar.

3. Everglades All Purpose Seasoning

Average Price: around $14.62/16oz 

Why We Love It: We like Everglades seasoning because it’s an all-rounder in the kitchen. But we super like burgers and steak. 

Its tropical flavor comes from the unripe flesh of a powdered Papaya.

However, if you’re very health-conscious, you’ll want to pass on this, as Everglades seasoning contains MSG. 

But this is a good buy if you’re like us and that taste and flavor matter.

2. Historic Lynchburg Tennessee Whisky Steak & Burger Seasoning

Average Price: around $11.99/6oz

Why We Love It: This Historic Lynchburg Tennessee Whisky seasoning is the first truly unique blend of ingredients we have ever used for burgers. 

There’s no sugar, but it has the sweet flavor of Jack Daniel’s whiskey.

In fact, Historic Lynchburg’s burger seasoning is primarily intended for use as a BBQ rub, but in burgers, it’s equally delicious. 

We suggest you also try this in potatoes, vegetables, and meat.

1. Weber Gourmet Burger Seasoning

Average Price: Around $4.26/8oz

Why We Love It: This perfect burger seasoning blends garlic, onion, salt, and spices, adding delicious flavors to any burger. 

This mix includes other great ingredients, such as chili pepper [1]  and sweet and savory spices.

We like Weber’s Gourmet burger seasoning, as it’s gluten-free, kosher, and contains no artificial preservatives or MSG. 

Try to add this to your burgers or ground meat before they’re grilled. Trust us when we say that its unique flavor will stand out from the rest.

**Average prices are based on Amazon. Price may vary depending on stores. 

FAQs

All Things Considered

Not all burgers seasonings can give the same flavorful taste. Some brands really stood out from others, and from our years of making burgers, these seasonings on the list are the most recommended. 

With Lawry’s Seasoned Salt to Weber Gourmet Burger Seasoning, you’re burgers will never be the same plain and simple patty. It’s time to enhance your cooking, so pick the best burger seasoning. 

References:

1. https://www.britannica.com/plant/chili-pepper 
2. https://www.britannica.com/plant/black-pepper-plant