Best Shake At In-N-Out

15 Best Shake Options At In-N-Out Burger

Last Updated on May 17, 2024 by Shari Mason

Should you be looking for a way to cool down during the heat of summer, In-N-Out’s shakes present a tasty remedy. Their burgers and fries have a well-deserved reputation for popularity, but their shakes should not be overlooked and are also strongly suggested for patrons.

We’ll break down the different types of shakes offered at In-N-Out and provide expert tips on choosing the best one for your taste buds. 

So, let’s dive in and discover the best shake at In-N-Out.

Top 10 Shakes At In-N-Out You Need To Try

1. Vanilla Shake

Vanilla Shake on a Glass

Average Price: around $2.60

Why We Love It: Vanilla Shake is made from real ice cream, vanilla extract, and milk. It has a creamy and smooth texture, a sweet and rich flavor, with a strong vanilla taste.

The In-N-Out burger chain is known for using high-quality ingredients, and the Vanilla Shake is no exception. 

It also has 560 calories per serving. Thus, consuming more than one order may increase your calorie and sugar intake. This may lead to some health risks and weight gain. [1] 

2. Mint Chocolate Chip Shake

Average Price: around $2.15

Why We Love It: It is a creamy and refreshing beverage that combines the classic flavors of mint and chocolate. 

Made with real ice cream and blended with pieces of chocolate chips, it’s one of our favorites among the milkshake lists.

It’s a delicious treat that perfectly complements In-N-Out’s famous burgers and fries.

3. Coffee Shake

Glass of Coffee Milkshake

Average Price: around $2.20

Why We Love It: The Coffee shake is a delicious and refreshing treat combining freshly brewed coffee and creamy vanilla ice cream. 

“Indulge in the tantalizing symphony of flavor as In-N-Out burger shakes swirl their way into your soul, transforming mere sips into euphoric moments of pure bliss.”

Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

This coffee shake is perfect for cream-based drinks with a caffeine kick for extra energy. 

Coffee is a natural energy booster and could protect our livers from diseases. [2] 

4. Black & White Shake

Average Price: around $2.20

Why We Love It: It is a classic American dessert with vanilla ice cream and chocolate syrup. 

The rich and creamy vanilla ice cream is perfectly balanced with the decadent chocolate syrup, creating a smooth and satisfying taste. 

The Black and White shake is perfect and will satisfy any sweet tooth.

5. Neapolitan Shake

Average Price: around $2.10

Why We Love It: This Neopolitan Shake combines three flavors of milkshakes: chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry. 

This shake is made with natural ice cream and is mixed to perfection, creating a deliciously creamy treat with a balanced blend of flavors.

It is also one of the best secret menus at In-n-Out Burger.

6. Banana Shake

Banana Shake on a Mug

Average Price: around $2.20

Why We Love It: This delicious dessert option combines creamy vanilla ice cream and real bananas blended to create a smooth and flavorful shake.

The shake is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and contains no artificial colors, preservatives/flavors.

It’s a refreshing treat that is perfect to be enjoyed on its own or alongside one of In-N-Out’s classic burgers. 

7. Oreo Shake

Average Price: around $2.20

Why We Love It: The In-N-Out Oreo shake is made by blending vanilla ice cream and Oreo cookie pieces, resulting in a creamy and decadent treat with a crunchy texture. 

We also enjoyed that we could customize our shake by requesting extra Oreo pieces or whipped cream. 

8. Strawberry Shake

Glass of Strawberry Shake

Average Price: around $2.60

Why We Love It: We definitely love that this classic strawberry shake is made with real strawberries and vanilla ice cream. 

It is a delicious treat perfect for satisfying our sweet tooth or cooling down on a hot day. The shake has a creamy texture and a refreshing fruity flavor that’s not overpowering. 

It’s a must-try for anyone who loves classic milkshakes with a fruity twist.

9. Chocolate Shake

Average Price: around $2.65

Why We Love It: We enjoy its creamy and indulgent milkshake made with natural ice cream and chocolate syrup. 

The shake has a rich chocolate flavor that’s not too sweet, making it perfect for satisfying chocolate cravings. 

Chocolate makes us happy by just eating them. It is proven that chocolates help our brain release endorphins to feel happy, and this chocolate shake does its job better. [3] 

10. Root Beer Float Shake

Glass of Root Beer Float

Average Price: around $2.10

Why We Love It: The Root Beer Float Shake is a perfect treat for anyone who loves the traditional combination of root beer and ice cream. 

It is a unique twist on the classic root beer float. It is made with creamy vanilla ice cream and root beer soda, creating a refreshing and creamy combination of flavors.

“It Is Health That Is Real Wealth And Not Pieces Of Gold And Silver.”

– Mahatma Gandhi, Lawyer & Anti-colonial Nationalist

The shake has a smooth and creamy texture and is topped with whipped cream for indulgence. 


u003cstrongu003eHow many milkshake flavors does In-N-Out have?u003c/strongu003e

In-N-Out Burger offers three classic milkshake flavors: vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. Depending on your preferences, these milkshakes, made with real ice cream, can be customized.

u003cstrongu003eIs there a secret In-N-Out milkshake menu?u003c/strongu003e

Yes, there is a “secret” milkshake menu at In-N-Out. It has a few flavors that aren’t on the regular menu but might only be offered at some locations, and some employees might not even know about them.u003cbru003eu003cbru003eSome popular “secret” milkshake tastes at In-N-Out are Neapolitan (a mix of vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry), chocolate banana, and root beer float.

u003cstrongu003eHow many calories do In-N-Out milkshakes have?u003c/strongu003e

Each serving of their milkshakes contains approximately 590 to 640 calories, depending on the flavor. u003cbru003eu003cbru003eIt’s worth noting that In-N-Out milkshakes are high in calories and should be taken in moderation as part of a balanced diet to prevent weight gain. u003ca href=u0022[u003c/au003eu003ca href=u0022 target=u0022_blanku0022 rel=u0022noreferrer noopeneru0022u003e4u003c/au003eu003ca href=u0022]u003c/au003e 

In Summary 

To summarize, Vanilla Shake is In-N-Out’s best shake because of its classic flavor, versatility, and customization. 

This dessert can be paired with any of their menus and is an excellent choice on its own as a treat. Because of its classic vanilla flavor, you can add toppings for extra flavor.

“The best In-N-Out shake is a heavenly blend of nostalgia and indulgence, with classic flavors that stand the test of time.”

– Eat Pallet, Restaurant & Food Advice

Overall, all In-N-Out shakes are plentiful and delicious on their own; depending on your taste preference, the list above is undoubtedly a must-try on your visit.


Shari Mason

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *