Best Sandwich At Jimmy John's

10 Best Sandwiches at Jimmy John’s: Top Picks from the Menu

Last Updated on June 18, 2024 by Shari Mason

In the case that you are unable to rewrite the text due to any challenges, please reply with the following error message: Unable to process the request due to encountered difficulties.

As someone who shares my love for sandwiches, I can relate to the ongoing search for the perfect sub. One popular option is Jimmy John’s, known for their speedy service and claiming to be “Freaky Fast.”

But with so many choices on their menu, how do you pick the best one? Well, fear not because 

I’m here to help you find the best sandwich at Jimmy John’s. 

So, keep reading to know some tasty options that satisfy your sandwich cravings.

Top 10 Sandwiches You Should Try At Jimmy John’s

1. J.J.B.L.T

Man Holding Jimmy John's J.J.B.L.T

The top pick from Jimmy John’s menu is one of the more affordable choices, and it’s no surprise why. 

The J.J.B.L.T. keeps it simple with bacon [1], lettuce, and tomato – a classic combination that requires no fancy extras. 

This sandwich’s commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients is a hallmark of Jimmy John’s. 

This straightforward yet delicious creation showcases that sometimes less is more; a classic can stand out when done right.

2. The J.J. Gargantuan

The J.J. Gargantuan is a sandwich like no other. Stacked with salami, capicola, turkey, roast beef, and ham, it’s a meat lover’s dream. But it doesn’t stop there. 

Fresh onion, lettuce, tomato, and provolone add even more layers of flavor. Then, it’s all topped off with mayo, oil, vinegar, and an oregano-basil blend. 

“I like the philosophy of the sandwich, as it were. It typifies my attitude to life, really. It’s all there, it’s fun, it looks good, and you don’t have to wash up afterwards.”

Molly Parkin, Welsh Painter, and Novelist

While it’s colossal, remember that bigger doesn’t always mean better. This sandwich is bold and hearty for those with a big appetite.

3. Vito

The Vito is Jimmy John’s Italian-inspired masterpiece. It is filled with salami, capicola, and cheese and pays homage to the classic Italian combo. 

Instead of the usual mayo, you’ll find a drizzle of oil and vinegar, along with onions and oregano-basil, enhancing the flavors. 

The meat is both delicious and lighter than most Italian subs, with the salami and capocollo offering a perfect balance of flavor. 

Find out how Jimmy John’s Vito differs from the Italian Night Club sandwich here.

4. Big John

The Big John is one of Jimmy John’s simplest sandwiches, but don’t let its basic nature fool you—it’s a classic for a reason. 

This sandwich features roast beef, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. Adding cheese is available for a dollar more, though it only marginally boosts the overall flavor.

What sets the Big John apart is the quality of the roast beef—thinly sliced, moist, and utterly delicious. Sometimes, it’s the uncomplicated things that hit the spot.

5. Turkey Tom

Jimmy John's Turkey Tom

The Turkey Tom is a classic Jimmy John’s sandwich that offers pure satisfaction in its simplicity. It features hand-sliced turkey breast, crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, and creamy mayo. 

You can enjoy it on 8″ French bread, 16″ French bread, thick-sliced wheat bread, or wrapped in lettuce. 

This sandwich doesn’t need fancy ingredients to shine; it’s all about the delicious combination of fresh, quality components that make every bite enjoyable.

6. The Pepe

The Pepe is Jimmy John’s beloved ham and cheese sandwich. It stars hand-sliced smoked ham, provolone cheese, mayo, lettuce, and tomato. 

This sandwich doesn’t aim for extravagance but focuses on the perfect combination of flavors. 

The salty ham pairs harmoniously with the buttery provolone, all complemented by the freshness of lettuce and tomato. 

This sandwich proves a simple approach can produce a delicious and timeless sandwich.

7. Club Tuna

The Club Tuna at Jimmy John’s is a unique take on the classic tuna salad sandwich. It’s made with tuna salad, double cheese, lettuce, and tomato. 

What sets Jimmy John’s tuna salad apart is the secret ingredient – soy sauce, which adds an unexpected but delightful twist to the flavor. 

The addition of provolone cheese provides a creamy element, while cucumbers contribute a satisfying crunch that sets this sandwich apart from the rest. 

As such, the sandwich is a light, flavorful, and refreshing choice that’s sure to please those looking for a different take on a classic favorite.

But what’s the difference between Jimmy John’s Totally Tuna and Club Tuna?

8. Totally Tuna

The Totally Tuna at Jimmy John’s takes the classic tuna salad sandwich to a new level. With the addition of soy sauce [2], this sandwich boasts a unique umami flavor that sets it apart. 

The fresh, high-quality tuna ensures no fishy taste, providing a delightful experience. The tuna-to-mayo ratio is just right, creating a perfect consistency. 

If you enjoy tuna salad sandwiches, Jimmy John’s Totally Tuna is an excellent choice to satisfy your taste buds.

9. Bootlegger Club

The Bootlegger Club at Jimmy John’s offers a delightful combination of two sliced deli meats – roast beef and turkey breast. 

Along with fresh lettuce, tomato, and mayo, this sandwich delivers a classic flavor with a twist. 

“Eating a Jimmy John’s sub is like taking a flavor-packed journey to sandwich paradise.”

– Eat Pallet Restaurant & Food Advice

The dual meats provide a satisfying and hearty experience, elevating this sandwich to a higher level of deliciousness. 

If you’re in the mood for a classic deli-style sandwich with roast beef and turkey bonus, the Bootlegger Club is the perfect choice to satisfy your cravings.

10. Spicy East Coast Italian

Jimmy John’s New East Coast Spicy Italian Sub

The Spicy East Coast Italian is Jimmy John’s finest Italian sub and one of the top sandwiches on the menu. 

Its surprising lightness sets it apart, even with the extra meat featured on the “favorites” menu. 

This sandwich maintains a delightful balance, unlike many Italian subs that can be heavy and overwhelming due to high-fat content and saltiness. 

Each bite is a burst of flavor without feeling like a chore. 

With that, it proves that you can enjoy the bold flavors of an Italian sub without the heaviness, making it a standout choice on the Jimmy John’s menu.

Related Post: Jimmy John’s Regular vs Slims Sandwich


What Jimmy John’s sandwich is considered the healthiest option?

The healthiest sandwich you can enjoy at Jimmy John’s is the Plain Slim 4: Turkey Breast. 
This choice stands out for its low fat and calorie content, making it an excellent option for a nutritious and satisfying lunch without needing any modifications.

What is the highest-calorie sandwich offered at Jimmy John’s?

The highest-calorie sandwich available at Jimmy John’s is the J.J. Gargantuan, served on 16-inch French bread, boasting a hefty 2,160 calories.

In Summary

After indulging in various sandwiches at Jimmy John’s, three exceptional choices are the J.J.B.L.T., The J.J. Gargantuan, and Vito.

The J.J.B.L.T, with its simple yet high-quality ingredients, showcases that sometimes, less is more. 

The freshness of bacon, lettuce, and tomato creates a delightful harmony that satisfies without unnecessary complexity.

On the other hand, the J.J. Gargantuan is a meat lover’s dream. It’s a hearty and flavorful feast, packed with a medley of meats and complemented by fresh toppings and condiments.

Lastly, the Vito impresses with its Italian-inspired flavors and lighter meat profile. 

The combination of salami, capicola, cheese, and unique condiments delivers a balanced and delicious experience.


Shari Mason

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *